Krzysztof Szczawiński Essays

Culture through books and films

The Iliad is not about the Trojan War. It opens in its tenth year — the war almost over, the men exhausted, the end in sight — and closes before the war concludes. It is about what war costs from the inside, without distance, without the mercy of a conclusion.

1. The first word of the poem is “rage.” Not glory, not war, not courage. Rage. The entire catastrophe — ten years, thousands of deaths, a civilization destroyed — flows from one man’s wounded ego. Agamemnon takes Achilles’ prize. Achilles withdraws. The Greeks start dying. Homer names this on the first line because he wants you to carry it through every death that follows: all of this, for this.

2. Achilles is not a hero in any sense we find comfortable. He is the greatest warrior who ever lived, and he knows it, and he uses that knowledge as a weapon against his own side. He is capable of tenderness — his love for Patroclus is the emotional spine of the poem — and of something barely human in his rage. He desecrates Hector’s body, dragging it behind his chariot. He is magnificent and monstrous simultaneously. Homer doesn’t resolve this. He holds both at once.

3. Fate is known in advance. Achilles has a choice – long life in obscurity, or glory and early death. He chooses glory with full knowledge of the cost. This is the Iliad’s answer to the Odyssey: two poems, two heroes, two opposite arguments. Odysseus chooses home, mortality, the particular. Achilles chooses legend, death, the eternal. Both poems know what the other costs.

4. In the middle of the war, Homer stops everything to describe the shield Hephaestus forges for Achilles. On it: cities at peace, weddings, harvests, dancing, the ocean, the full richness of the world not at war. Homer inserts the entire civilization inside the weapon – showing what is being destroyed by it. This is the greatest anti-war statement in the poem, and it contains not a single pacifist word.

5. The gods make everything worse. They intervene not to save anyone but to extend the suffering on behalf of their own favorites and quarrels. The Iliad’s cosmos is not just. It is beautiful, terrible, and indifferent. Men die heroically for causes the gods treat as entertainment. There is no meaning assigned from above. Only the meaning the men make for themselves – which is the most modern thing about a poem three thousand years old.

6. Priam walks alone into Achilles’ camp to beg for his son’s body. Achilles, who has been barely human in grief and rage, looks at the old king and sees his own father. They weep together. Two enemies who have lost everything, sharing grief in a tent, in the middle of a war that has destroyed both their worlds. The most human moment in Western literature – inside the most brutal text. Homer puts it there deliberately: the war doesn’t pause. The humanity doesn’t disappear. Both are true simultaneously.

7. The Iliad ends with Hector’s funeral. Troy has not yet fallen. Achilles has not yet died. Homer closes on grief, not victory – because that is what he thought the poem was actually about. Not who won. What it cost. Every war since has had its Iliads – the official version that records the outcome, and the true version that records the cost. Homer wrote the true version first. Most wars are still waiting for theirs.